Home
About
Substack Blog
Murder at the Sexton
Home
About
Substack Blog
Murder at the Sexton
More
  • Home
  • About
  • Substack Blog
  • Murder at the Sexton
  • Sign In
  • Create Account

  • Bookings
  • My Account
  • Signed in as:

  • filler@godaddy.com


  • Bookings
  • My Account
  • Sign out

Signed in as:

filler@godaddy.com

  • Home
  • About
  • Substack Blog
  • Murder at the Sexton

Account

  • Bookings
  • My Account
  • Sign out

  • Sign In
  • Bookings
  • My Account

Theodore is Savannah's best True-Crime expert. He's better than the police. He's telling all.


Theodore Penny

A Fake True-Crime Show

Theodore Penny is Savannah's most impressive True-Crime aficionado. He's collected incredible stories from around Savannah and now he's revealing them at a one-of-a-kind presentation. You've been invited. You don't have anything to hide, do you? 


Only 5 Shows this Holiday Season

The Sexton Pub - Starland District

9 W 43rd St

Doors Open 6:30pm, Show at 7:00pm

$40

Includes 1 Free drink and bar snacks


This show is open to the public. No pre-prep required. It is an interactive cocktail party with audience participation. Pre-purchase of tickets strongly encouraged.  


FAQ Below


Show Dates

Premiere - Nov 20

Premiere - Nov 20

Premiere - Nov 20

7:00-9:00pm
Fake True-Crime 

Murder Mystery
$40, includes FREE drink


Grand Success!

Dec 3

Premiere - Nov 20

Premiere - Nov 20

7:00-9:00pm
Fake True-Crime
Murder Mystery
$40, includes FREE drink


A Stunning Triumph!

Dec 4

Premiere - Nov 20

Dec 10

7:00-9:00pm
Fake True-Crime
Murder Mystery

$40, includes FREE drink


Critics Are Raving!

Dec 10

Closing Night - Dec 11

Dec 10

7:00-9:00pm
Fake True-Crime
Murder Mystery

$40, includes FREE drink

SOLD OUT!

Closing Night - Dec 11

Closing Night - Dec 11

Closing Night - Dec 11

7:00-9:00pm

Fake True-Crime
Murder Mystery

$40, includes FREE drink

Big, Bold and Beautiful! 

Frequently Asked Questions

Please reach us at GregAustin@twopennytales.com if you cannot find an answer to your question.

No performance required. The show will take the form of a cocktail party with a presentation by Mr. Theodore Penny. When you arrive, we do ask that you make up a pretend name and choose a pretend occupation (such as Dog Walker) to build up the Who Dun It atmosphere for the night.


We'll have the entire upstairs of the Sexton to ourselves. It's a gorgeous space, decorated in classic Victorian style. We'll have a server to take care of our food and drink needs, so nothing distracts from the enjoyment of the show. You'll have plenty of time to mingle with your fellow guests while the presentations are made by Mr. Theodore Penny. Until something dramatic happens, of course!


Then enjoy the fun as we all try to solve the crime.


Yes, the show is perfect for date nights, family get-togethers, and night outs with friends.


The show tackles adult themes, so we ask for 18+ guests.



Copyright © 2025 Two Penny Tales - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept